The 'nameplate dispute' is currently under hearing at the Supreme Court. During Monday's debate, senior advocate CU Singh, representing the petitioner, mentioned that Shiv Dhaba is a chain spread across India. It can be managed by anyone, be it Sikh, Muslim, or Christian. The bench inquired if there's an official government order mandating this display since it is said to be voluntary. In response, senior advocate Singhvi termed this a pseudo order.
Representing the petitioner, senior advocate CU Singh said, 'Two more states have issued notifications.' The bench of Justices Hrishikesh Roy and SV Bhatti is hearing the case. CU Singh, on behalf of the NGO Association of Civil Rights, asked, 'When was it issued?' Singh read out the notification, stating that this had never been done before and lacked statutory backing. No law grants such authority to the Police Commissioner. This directive applies to every pushcart, street vendor, and tea shop. Naming employees and owners brings no benefit.
Read more: 'No need for name identification on shops,' SC interim stay on UP government order
Mostly small tea or fruit shops
Regarding the Kanwar Yatra, Singhvi said, 'The court is strict against those violating rules, and it becomes even stricter when people act cleverly and camouflage. Penalties will be imposed on violators, and failure to do so means we're talking about thousands of kilometers, most of which consist of small tea or fruit shops, leading to economic death.' The bench responded, 'Please do not exaggerate statements. Security, standards, and secularism are all important aspects.'
Started in Muzaffarnagar
In fact, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath has issued necessary instructions before the Kanwar Yatra. According to the government, it will be mandatory for the owner of every food establishment along the roadside, including carts, to display a board with their name. This rule began in Muzaffarnagar the day before. The local administration instructed shop owners and operators along the Kanwar travelers' route to display their names. This rule will now be implemented throughout the state. On July 19, Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath conducted a review meeting with officials and directed that every shop owner and operator’s name be displayed along the Kanwar travelers' route throughout the state. The Chief Minister has also ordered action against those selling halal products. Several opposition leaders have urged the UP government to withdraw this order.
